{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "id": "evidence-relationship-authority:issue-387:2026-08-11", "artifact_id": "artifact:inference-at-the-ambiguity-frontier", "governing_issue": 387, "repair_issue": 391, "skills_correction_issue": "pinklon/skills#182", "created": "2026-08-11", "accessed_date": "2026-08-11", "status": "complete-pending-hosted-validation", "authority_axes": { "semantic": "complete", "evidence": "complete-pending-hosted-validation", "relationships": "complete-pending-hosted-validation", "creative": "complete", "implementation": "existing-draft-repair-in-progress", "render_uat": "historically-green-at-05dac544dc4a0787eedfaa1f7a342a84ed4773db", "owner_acceptance": "withheld-after-authority-repair", "merge": "not-authorized", "production": "not-authorized" }, "policy": { "canonical_sequence": "Source intake -> semantic development -> evidence and claim binding -> Semantic Authority Complete -> Information Design -> Creative Lock -> implementation -> validation/UAT", "freshness_policy": "write-in-tonys-voice v1.6 rolling evidence freshness", "current_state_window_days": 180, "rule": "A governing issue or accepted visual may prove owner authority and lineage but does not count as independent external corroboration." }, "sources": [ { "id": "source:shareplane-platform-issue-387", "title": "Inference at the Ambiguity Frontier", "locator": "https://github.com/pinklon/shareplane-platform/issues/387", "authority_class": "owner-semantic-and-publication-authority", "evidence_role": "uniquely-authoritative", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:primary","claim:ambiguity-frontier:system-autonomy","claim:ambiguity-frontier:interchangeability","claim:ambiguity-frontier:idr"], "publishedDate": "2026-08-11", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 0, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "internal-owner-authority", "publiclyExposed": true }, { "id": "source:issue-387-accepted-visual", "title": "Accepted standalone HTML visual authority", "locator": "SHA-256 4fea07addc1a3cfad760733dc7aa5c509699a79c793d151b939d43dd27640649", "authority_class": "owner-accepted-visual-authority", "evidence_role": "uniquely-authoritative", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:idr"], "publishedDate": "2026-08-11", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 0, "domainVelocity": "moderate", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "internal-visual-authority", "publiclyExposed": true }, { "id": "source:shareplane-platform-pr-231", "title": "Issue #230: build-once publication Fast Path v01", "locator": "https://github.com/pinklon/shareplane-platform/pull/231", "authority_class": "repository-primary-field-evidence", "evidence_role": "current-operating", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:field-evidence"], "publishedDate": "2026-07-31", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 11, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "internal-field-evidence", "publiclyExposed": true, "evidence_summary": "The PR records a representative before/after change from eight full builds and two Development deployments to one build and one deployment, with the same exact artifact reused through validation and protected Development." }, { "id": "source:google-adk-2", "title": "Why we built ADK 2.0", "locator": "https://developers.googleblog.com/why-we-built-adk-20/", "authority_class": "primary-vendor-engineering", "evidence_role": "current-operating", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:primary","claim:ambiguity-frontier:economics","claim:ambiguity-frontier:variance","claim:ambiguity-frontier:system-autonomy","claim:ambiguity-frontier:maturity"], "publishedDate": "2026-07-01", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 41, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "external-primary-corroboration", "publiclyExposed": true }, { "id": "source:openai-workspace-agents", "title": "Workspace agents", "locator": "https://openai.com/academy/workspace-agents/", "authority_class": "primary-vendor-guidance", "evidence_role": "current-operating", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:primary","claim:ambiguity-frontier:variance"], "publishedDate": "2026-04-22", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 111, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "external-primary-corroboration", "publiclyExposed": true }, { "id": "source:anthropic-managed-agents", "title": "Scaling Managed Agents: Decoupling the brain from the hands", "locator": "https://www.anthropic.com/engineering/managed-agents", "authority_class": "primary-vendor-engineering", "evidence_role": "current-operating", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:primary","claim:ambiguity-frontier:system-autonomy","claim:ambiguity-frontier:interchangeability"], "publishedDate": "2026-04-08", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 125, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "external-primary-corroboration", "publiclyExposed": true }, { "id": "source:openai-agents-transforming-work", "title": "How agents are transforming work", "locator": "https://openai.com/index/how-agents-are-transforming-work/", "authority_class": "primary-vendor-empirical-context", "evidence_role": "current-operating", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:maturity"], "publishedDate": "2026-06-25", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 47, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "external-primary-counterevidence", "publiclyExposed": true, "evidence_summary": "Agentic usage and task horizons are expanding, which limits any interpretation that system maturity universally reduces total model usage." }, { "id": "source:compiled-ai-2604-05150", "title": "Compiled AI: Deterministic Code Generation for LLM-Based Workflow Automation", "locator": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.05150", "authority_class": "research-preprint", "evidence_role": "foundational", "supports": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:economics","claim:ambiguity-frontier:maturity"], "publishedDate": "2026-04-06", "accessedDate": "2026-08-11", "sourceAgeDays": 127, "domainVelocity": "fast-moving", "freshnessException": null, "exceptionRationale": null, "classification": "external-research-and-prior-art", "publiclyExposed": true } ], "claims": [ {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:primary","class":"owner-thesis","evidence_required":"corroboration-not-proof","corroboration_result":"supported-by-current-primary-engineering-sources","support":["source:shareplane-platform-issue-387","source:google-adk-2","source:openai-workspace-agents","source:anthropic-managed-agents"],"caveat":"Placement principle, not universal elimination of inference.","unresolved_risk":null}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:economics","class":"external-factual-bounded","evidence_required":"yes","corroboration_result":"supported","support":["source:google-adk-2","source:compiled-ai-2604-05150"],"caveat":"Magnitude is workload-specific; article equations are conceptual, not measured universal cost formulas.","unresolved_risk":null}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:variance","class":"external-factual-bounded","evidence_required":"yes","corroboration_result":"supported","support":["source:google-adk-2","source:openai-workspace-agents"],"caveat":"Orchestration-level claim, not deterministic-model-inference claim.","unresolved_risk":null}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:system-autonomy","class":"owner-operating-principle","evidence_required":"corroboration","corroboration_result":"supported","support":["source:shareplane-platform-issue-387","source:google-adk-2","source:anthropic-managed-agents"],"caveat":"Minimum necessary inference varies by task and risk.","unresolved_risk":null}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:maturity","class":"bounded-inference","evidence_required":"yes-plus-counterevidence","corroboration_result":"supported-with-material-qualification","support":["source:google-adk-2","source:compiled-ai-2604-05150","source:openai-agents-transforming-work"],"caveat":"Solved subpaths may become deterministic while total agent use expands into harder work.","unresolved_risk":null}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:field-evidence","class":"owner-observation-repository-observed","evidence_required":"repository-primary","corroboration_result":"supported-in-scope","support":["source:shareplane-platform-pr-231"],"caveat":"One evolving system, not a controlled comparative study.","unresolved_risk":"Control Tower-specific examples remain owner testimony unless separately bound to exact Control Tower receipts."}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:interchangeability","class":"owner-architecture-judgment","evidence_required":"corroboration","corroboration_result":"supported-in-separation-of-concerns","support":["source:shareplane-platform-issue-387","source:anthropic-managed-agents"],"caveat":"Models remain operationally different even when architecture avoids making one model the durable system.","unresolved_risk":null}, {"id":"claim:ambiguity-frontier:idr","class":"proposed-metric","evidence_required":"prior-art-disposition-not-empirical-proof","corroboration_result":"owner-proposal-only","support":["source:shareplane-platform-issue-387","source:issue-387-accepted-visual"],"caveat":"Not standardized, validated, or claimed original.","unresolved_risk":"Requires empirical validation before being presented as a predictive or comparative metric."} ], "freshness_receipt": { "domain_velocity": "fast-moving", "current_state_claims": ["claim:ambiguity-frontier:economics","claim:ambiguity-frontier:variance","claim:ambiguity-frontier:maturity","claim:ambiguity-frontier:interchangeability"], "within_180_day_authoritative_support": { "claim:ambiguity-frontier:economics": ["source:google-adk-2"], "claim:ambiguity-frontier:variance": ["source:google-adk-2","source:openai-workspace-agents"], "claim:ambiguity-frontier:maturity": ["source:google-adk-2","source:openai-agents-transforming-work"], "claim:ambiguity-frontier:interchangeability": ["source:anthropic-managed-agents"] }, "materially_newer_authoritative_evidence_considered": ["source:google-adk-2","source:openai-agents-transforming-work"], "omitted_newer_evidence_justification": null, "freshness_exceptions": [], "result": "pass-for-authority-repair" }, "prior_art": { "construct": "Inference Dependency Ratio (IDR)", "search_date": "2026-08-11", "search_terms": ["\"Inference Dependency Ratio\" AI","\"inference dependency\" ratio AI systems","\"model call\" ratio agent architecture deterministic workflow","\"LLM\" deterministic workflow cost latency variance"], "source_classes_searched": ["web search","primary vendor engineering/guidance","recent research"], "exact_name_collision": "none-material-found-in-bounded-search", "adjacent_prior_art": [ {"source":"source:compiled-ai-2604-05150","relationship":"strong-adjacent","note":"Explicitly compiles probabilistic model output into deterministic executable workflows and studies inference amortization."}, {"source":"source:google-adk-2","relationship":"strong-adjacent","note":"Explicitly separates deterministic application flow from LLM reasoning for production agents."}, {"source":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.13092","title":"PlanCompiler: A Deterministic Compilation Architecture for Structured Multi-Step LLM Pipelines","relationship":"adjacent","note":"Separates planning from deterministic compiled execution in structured workflows."} ], "originality_posture": "no-originality-claim", "disposition": "IDR is retained as Tony Malott's proposed label and ratio for this architecture thesis, with explicit acknowledgment that the broader deterministic-compilation and selective-inference pattern has substantial prior art. No claim is made that the underlying architecture or the general idea of reducing repeated inference is novel." }, "relationship_decisions": [ {"candidate":"artifact:the-code-is-no-longer-the-hard-part","considered_because":"Direct conceptual predecessor on implementation-cost inversion and the growing importance of surrounding engineering systems.","disposition":"accepted","relationship_type":"foundation","reader_group":"foundations","label":"Start with the engineering cost inversion","resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"This Work extends the prior cost-inversion thesis into an explicit placement rule for inference."}, {"candidate":"artifact:stop-prompting-agents-start-managing-workers","considered_because":"Existing worker-management foundation for bounded authority, evidence, and earned autonomy.","disposition":"accepted","relationship_type":"foundation","reader_group":"foundations","label":"Start with the governed worker model","resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"The new Work asks which repeated worker decisions should be compiled out of the worker path."}, {"candidate":"artifact:the-agents-are-not-the-bottleneck-you-are","considered_because":"Existing continuation into human specification and review bottlenecks after execution accelerates.","disposition":"accepted","relationship_type":"continuation","reader_group":"continue","label":"Continue into the human-attention bottleneck","resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"Deterministic execution moves the remaining constraint toward human judgment and integration."}, {"candidate":"artifact:frontier-inference-without-frontier-custody","considered_because":"Existing companion governing what information may cross into frontier reasoning.","disposition":"accepted","relationship_type":"companion","reader_group":"companions","label":"Companion: control the inference boundary","resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"One Work governs custody at the boundary; this one governs where the boundary belongs."}, {"candidate":"artifact:the-most-expensive-model-is-often-compensation-for-missing-control","considered_because":"Direct economic/operational companion on reducing model dependence through stronger surrounding control.","disposition":"accepted","relationship_type":"companion","reader_group":"companions","label":"Companion: reduce model dependence through control","resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"It provides the model-routing/control corollary to the broader inference-placement thesis."}, {"candidate":"artifact:governed-static-publishing-lane","considered_because":"Concrete SharePlane example of stable publication decisions becoming reusable deterministic infrastructure.","disposition":"accepted","relationship_type":"application","reader_group":"applications","label":"See the pattern applied to publishing","resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"It turns the abstract thesis into a directly inspectable application in the author's system."}, {"candidate":"artifact:the-agent-is-not-the-product-the-control-plane-is","considered_because":"Strong conceptual overlap around externalizing durability, authority, evidence, and recovery from the agent.","disposition":"rejected-from-reader-navigation","relationship_type":null,"reader_group":null,"label":null,"resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"Semantically relevant, but the governed-worker foundation already serves this reader job more directly; adding both would crowd the same entry path. It remains graph-adjacent through existing corpus relationships."}, {"candidate":"artifact:a-publishing-system-that-remembers","considered_because":"Foundational SharePlane doctrine about durable publication, receipts, relationships, and reusable learning.","disposition":"rejected-from-reader-navigation","relationship_type":null,"reader_group":null,"label":null,"resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"Useful platform doctrine but less directly about inference placement than the accepted publishing-lane application."}, {"candidate":"artifact:the-semantic-operating-system","considered_because":"Related architecture for externalizing meaning, authority, state, and next-valid-action semantics.","disposition":"deferred","relationship_type":null,"reader_group":null,"label":null,"resolution":"canonical-target-resolves","rationale":"Conceptually adjacent but broad enough to distract from the specific inference/determinism reader path. Revisit only if a future collection or reciprocal relationship needs it."} ], "repair_boundary": { "accepted_visual_sha256": "4fea07addc1a3cfad760733dc7aa5c509699a79c793d151b939d43dd27640649", "article_body_changed": false, "interior_visual_grammar_changed": false, "production_mutations": 0, "control_tower_mutations": 0, "shared_workflow_mutations": 0, "next_required_step": "Serialize repaired artifact/provenance/graph surfaces, validate exact head, and run protected Development proof before owner acceptance can be reconsidered." } }