{
  "schemaVersion": "shareplane.work-portable-view.v1",
  "workId": "artifact:architecture-and-intent",
  "canonicalWorkId": "work:architecture-and-intent",
  "title": "Architecture and Intent",
  "classification": {
    "workType": "architecture-thesis",
    "treatmentClass": "flagship",
    "disclosure": "owner-uat-candidate",
    "publicSafe": true
  },
  "author": {
    "id": "person:tony-malott",
    "name": "Tony Malott"
  },
  "canonicalRecordSha256": "b7ed90da8a551d4db4c8ce9f0ed628edc90a0d190cf8bfc10ddbe34437f80769",
  "authorityDescriptorSha256": "662fa64e642526ddcf089e29c3e5bcc3cd66d15fd07273f37367051a3d3d092d",
  "nativeVersionId": "file-version:architecture-and-intent:v2-native:hosted:7004805953fc12be37390dc957dd608f",
  "nativeManifestSha256": "35f9f6297c9dea1743cd946b2a26b4cde7ebcf6a5fc47182f40739674a76bb43",
  "nativePackageSha256": "a6fd2bc51c5e416d6f2da531fe33c19ccc2f59279ae5f41a81221b1d831c1be7",
  "relationships": [
    {
      "schemaVersion": "1.0.0",
      "id": "relationship:architecture-intent-authored-by-tony",
      "sourceId": "work:architecture-and-intent",
      "targetId": "person:tony-malott",
      "predicate": "authored_by",
      "authorityDecisionId": "authority-decision:architecture-and-intent-v2-owner-uat",
      "provenanceEventIds": [
        "evidence-event:architecture-and-intent-v2-owner-uat"
      ],
      "temporalScope": {
        "validFrom": "2026-09-10T00:00:00Z",
        "validUntil": null
      },
      "standing": "active",
      "readerLabel": "Written by Tony Malott",
      "explanation": "Tony Malott is the author and semantic authority for Architecture and Intent V2."
    },
    {
      "schemaVersion": "1.0.0",
      "id": "relationship:architecture-intent-companion-review-plane",
      "sourceId": "work:architecture-and-intent",
      "targetId": "work:architecture-review-plane-interactive-concepts",
      "predicate": "companion_to",
      "authorityDecisionId": "authority-decision:architecture-and-intent-v2-owner-uat",
      "provenanceEventIds": [
        "evidence-event:architecture-and-intent-v2-reconstruction"
      ],
      "temporalScope": {
        "validFrom": "2026-09-10T00:00:00Z",
        "validUntil": null
      },
      "standing": "active",
      "readerLabel": "Companion: Architecture Review Plane",
      "explanation": "The interactive architecture-review concepts are a direct companion treatment of the architecture-of-intent problem."
    },
    {
      "schemaVersion": "1.0.0",
      "id": "relationship:architecture-intent-extends-control-plane",
      "sourceId": "work:architecture-and-intent",
      "targetId": "artifact:the-agent-is-not-the-product-the-control-plane-is",
      "predicate": "extends",
      "authorityDecisionId": "authority-decision:architecture-and-intent-v2-owner-uat",
      "provenanceEventIds": [
        "evidence-event:architecture-and-intent-v2-reconstruction"
      ],
      "temporalScope": {
        "validFrom": "2026-09-10T00:00:00Z",
        "validUntil": null
      },
      "standing": "active",
      "readerLabel": "Extends: The Agent Is Not the Product",
      "explanation": "Architecture and Intent extends the control-plane thesis by making authority, semantics, consequence, and stop conditions explicit architectural planes."
    },
    {
      "schemaVersion": "1.0.0",
      "id": "relationship:architecture-intent-companion-beyond-agent",
      "sourceId": "work:architecture-and-intent",
      "targetId": "artifact:beyond-the-agent",
      "predicate": "companion_to",
      "authorityDecisionId": "authority-decision:architecture-and-intent-v2-owner-uat",
      "provenanceEventIds": [
        "evidence-event:architecture-and-intent-v2-reconstruction"
      ],
      "temporalScope": {
        "validFrom": "2026-09-10T00:00:00Z",
        "validUntil": null
      },
      "standing": "active",
      "readerLabel": "Companion: Beyond the Agent",
      "explanation": "Beyond the Agent develops the institutional authority, verification, trust, and human-judgment concerns that Architecture and Intent models architecturally."
    },
    {
      "schemaVersion": "1.0.0",
      "id": "relationship:architecture-intent-companion-semantic-os",
      "sourceId": "work:architecture-and-intent",
      "targetId": "artifact:the-semantic-operating-system",
      "predicate": "companion_to",
      "authorityDecisionId": "authority-decision:architecture-and-intent-v2-owner-uat",
      "provenanceEventIds": [
        "evidence-event:architecture-and-intent-v2-reconstruction"
      ],
      "temporalScope": {
        "validFrom": "2026-09-10T00:00:00Z",
        "validUntil": null
      },
      "standing": "active",
      "readerLabel": "Companion: The Semantic Operating System",
      "explanation": "The Semantic Operating System provides a companion treatment of identity, semantics, authority, provenance, state, evidence, and relationships as durable operating context."
    }
  ],
  "evidence": [
    {
      "id": "evidence:nist-ai-600-1",
      "type": "external-corroboration",
      "authority": "National Institute of Standards and Technology",
      "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile",
      "published": "2024-07-26",
      "updated": "2026-04-08",
      "locator": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/artificial-intelligence-risk-management-framework-generative-artificial-intelligence",
      "role": "Corroborates lifecycle trustworthiness and risk-management treatment for generative AI systems; does not establish the two-plane architecture thesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "evidence:owasp-llm01-2025",
      "type": "external-corroboration",
      "authority": "OWASP GenAI Security Project",
      "title": "LLM01:2025 Prompt Injection",
      "locator": "https://genai.owasp.org/llmrisk/llm01-prompt-injection/",
      "role": "Corroborates that retrieved/external content can be untrusted and that RAG/relevance does not itself create a trustworthy authority boundary."
    },
    {
      "id": "evidence:owasp-llm06-2025",
      "type": "external-corroboration",
      "authority": "OWASP GenAI Security Project",
      "title": "LLM06:2025 Excessive Agency",
      "locator": "https://genai.owasp.org/llmrisk/llm062025-excessive-agency/",
      "role": "Corroborates least privilege, user-context authorization, constrained agency, and human approval for high-impact actions."
    },
    {
      "id": "evidence:eu-ai-act-article-14",
      "type": "legal-authority-bounded-scope",
      "authority": "European Union",
      "title": "Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, Article 14 — Human oversight",
      "version": "consolidated-2026-07-27",
      "locator": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02024R1689-20260727",
      "role": "Within the Regulation's applicable high-risk AI scope, corroborates oversight proportional to risk, autonomy and context, including intervention and safe stopping. It is not represented as a universal requirement for every AI system."
    },
    {
      "id": "evidence:w3c-prov-overview",
      "type": "technical-standard-family",
      "authority": "World Wide Web Consortium",
      "title": "PROV-Overview",
      "published": "2013-04-30",
      "locator": "https://www.w3.org/TR/prov-overview/",
      "role": "Corroborates explicit provenance for entities, activities and people, including use in assessing quality, reliability and trustworthiness; provenance is not equated with organizational authority."
    }
  ],
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "claim:architecture-intent:two-plane-thesis",
      "text": "Consequential AI architecture should model both technical capability and an architecture of intent covering authority, semantics, consequence, evidence and stop conditions.",
      "posture": "owner-doctrine",
      "evidenceDisposition": "externally-corroborated-not-derived",
      "supportedBy": [
        "evidence:nist-ai-600-1",
        "evidence:owasp-llm06-2025",
        "evidence:eu-ai-act-article-14"
      ],
      "caveat": "The two-plane formulation is Tony Malott's architecture synthesis; external sources corroborate constituent concerns rather than establish this exact model."
    },
    {
      "id": "claim:architecture-intent:relevance-not-authority",
      "text": "Accessibility, relevance and recency do not by themselves establish legitimate authority for a decision.",
      "posture": "owner-doctrine",
      "evidenceDisposition": "externally-corroborated-not-derived",
      "supportedBy": [
        "evidence:owasp-llm01-2025",
        "evidence:w3c-prov-overview"
      ],
      "caveat": "OWASP establishes untrusted external-context risk and W3C establishes provenance concepts; the organizational-authority distinction is the author's synthesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "claim:architecture-intent:capability-not-permission",
      "text": "Technical capability or permission to call a tool does not by itself establish legitimate authority to perform a consequential action.",
      "posture": "owner-doctrine",
      "evidenceDisposition": "externally-corroborated-not-derived",
      "supportedBy": [
        "evidence:owasp-llm06-2025"
      ],
      "caveat": "OWASP's least-privilege and user-authorization guidance corroborates the separation; the architecture formulation is original synthesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "claim:architecture-intent:autonomy-by-consequence",
      "text": "Autonomy should scale with consequence, with stronger authority, validation, evidence, observability, reversibility and oversight as impact rises.",
      "posture": "owner-doctrine",
      "evidenceDisposition": "externally-corroborated-not-derived",
      "supportedBy": [
        "evidence:owasp-llm06-2025",
        "evidence:eu-ai-act-article-14"
      ],
      "caveat": "The consequence ladder is a conceptual architecture model, not a quoted regulatory taxonomy."
    },
    {
      "id": "claim:architecture-intent:human-authority-transitions",
      "text": "Human judgment is most valuable at explicit authority transitions rather than as an unspecified generic human-in-the-loop box.",
      "posture": "owner-doctrine",
      "evidenceDisposition": "externally-corroborated-not-derived",
      "supportedBy": [
        "evidence:owasp-llm06-2025",
        "evidence:eu-ai-act-article-14"
      ],
      "caveat": "External authorities support meaningful oversight and approval; the authority-transition framing is the author's architecture model."
    },
    {
      "id": "claim:architecture-intent:provenance-not-authority",
      "text": "Provenance helps assess origin, reliability and trustworthiness, but provenance alone does not establish organizational decision authority.",
      "posture": "owner-doctrine",
      "evidenceDisposition": "partially-standard-grounded",
      "supportedBy": [
        "evidence:w3c-prov-overview"
      ],
      "caveat": "W3C defines provenance and its trust-assessment uses; the distinction between provenance and organizational authority is an architectural inference."
    }
  ],
  "lineage": {
    "relationship": "successor-version-of-same-work",
    "implementationInheritance": "none-required",
    "historicalSource": {
      "recordId": "artifact:pinklon/pinklon-shareplane-next:architecture-and-intent",
      "repository": "pinklon/pinklon-shareplane-next",
      "commit": "33d227f6000da2491f19209edde916d8846f287f",
      "path": "content/artifacts/architecture-and-intent/artifact.json",
      "sourceSha256": "faa4745d8551606d2c182672f876730cae4b036c4325d8ccf90ce10de314c402"
    },
    "posture": "V1 retained as immutable heritage/predecessor evidence; V2 is a ground-up successor presentation preserving the Work's core semantic intent.",
    "runtimeCanonicalRecordSha256": "b7ed90da8a551d4db4c8ce9f0ed628edc90a0d190cf8bfc10ddbe34437f80769"
  },
  "readerContinuation": {
    "schemaVersion": "shareplane.reader-continuation-projection.v1",
    "source": "governed-work-relationships",
    "authorityDescriptorSha256": "662fa64e642526ddcf089e29c3e5bcc3cd66d15fd07273f37367051a3d3d092d",
    "recommendationInferenceUsed": false,
    "graphFallback": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#graph",
    "continuations": [
      {
        "relationshipId": "relationship:architecture-intent-companion-beyond-agent",
        "predicate": "companion_to",
        "targetId": "artifact:beyond-the-agent",
        "readerLabel": "Companion: Beyond the Agent",
        "title": "Beyond the Agent",
        "explanation": "Beyond the Agent develops the institutional authority, verification, trust, and human-judgment concerns that Architecture and Intent models architecturally.",
        "routeStatus": "AVAILABLE",
        "href": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/artifacts/beyond-the-agent/"
      },
      {
        "relationshipId": "relationship:architecture-intent-companion-review-plane",
        "predicate": "companion_to",
        "targetId": "work:architecture-review-plane-interactive-concepts",
        "readerLabel": "Companion: Architecture Review Plane",
        "title": "Architecture Review Plane: Three Interactive Product Concepts",
        "explanation": "The interactive architecture-review concepts are a direct companion treatment of the architecture-of-intent problem.",
        "routeStatus": "UNRESOLVED",
        "href": null
      },
      {
        "relationshipId": "relationship:architecture-intent-companion-semantic-os",
        "predicate": "companion_to",
        "targetId": "artifact:the-semantic-operating-system",
        "readerLabel": "Companion: The Semantic Operating System",
        "title": "The Semantic Operating System",
        "explanation": "The Semantic Operating System provides a companion treatment of identity, semantics, authority, provenance, state, evidence, and relationships as durable operating context.",
        "routeStatus": "AVAILABLE",
        "href": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/artifacts/the-semantic-operating-system/"
      },
      {
        "relationshipId": "relationship:architecture-intent-extends-control-plane",
        "predicate": "extends",
        "targetId": "artifact:the-agent-is-not-the-product-the-control-plane-is",
        "readerLabel": "Extends: The Agent Is Not the Product",
        "title": "The Agent Is Not the Product. The Control Plane Is.",
        "explanation": "Architecture and Intent extends the control-plane thesis by making authority, semantics, consequence, and stop conditions explicit architectural planes.",
        "routeStatus": "AVAILABLE",
        "href": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/artifacts/the-agent-is-not-the-product-the-control-plane-is/"
      }
    ],
    "nonReaderRelationships": [
      {
        "relationshipId": "relationship:architecture-intent-authored-by-tony",
        "predicate": "authored_by",
        "targetId": "person:tony-malott",
        "classification": "NON_READER_RELATIONSHIP"
      }
    ],
    "counts": {
      "activeRelationshipCount": 5,
      "continuationCount": 4,
      "nonReaderRelationshipCount": 1,
      "availableCount": 3,
      "unavailableCount": 0,
      "unresolvedCount": 1
    },
    "silentOmissionCount": 0
  },
  "shellNavigation": {
    "work": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#work",
    "latest": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#latest",
    "graph": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#graph",
    "architecture": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#architecture",
    "learning": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#learning",
    "philosophy": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#philosophy",
    "origin": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#origin"
  },
  "standing": "protected-owner-uat",
  "shellInteraction": {
    "searchTarget": "https://shareplane.malott.ai/#work",
    "searchNavigation": "same-tab-qualified-v5-search-surface",
    "ghostMeshTarget": "https://ghostmesh.ai/",
    "ghostMeshNavigation": "same-tab",
    "authorAttribution": "subordinate-byline",
    "nestedBrandAnchorAllowed": false
  }
}